|
When
talking of gas treating, it is most
often implied that
natural gas is the
focus. The natural gas industry is one
of the World’s
largest. However, there is also
treatment of gas in the synthesis gas
industry, and there are a number of
processes used for this that are similar
to those used for natural gas treatment.
Finally, there is a large industry
devoted to separate air to make
nitrogen, oxygen and argon, and to an
extent, krypton and xenon. Such plants
would be cryogenic distillation outfits
for large capacities while adsorption
and membranes are also in use for
smaller units. There is also an emerging
interest in CO2 removal from flue gases
caused by the focus on CO2’s
role in global warming.
The term
gas treating
is normally used to cover CO2 removal,
H2S removal, water removal, hydrocarbon
dew pointing and gas sweetening. Gas
sweetening is a generic term for sulfur
removal. Sometimes the term
‘gas
conditioning’
is used instead of gas treating.
The key question is
‘why
treat gas?’
This is a multi-faceted issue. The gas
is produced from a well at a location
where there is usually only a negligible
market for it. Transport of the gas to
the market is the first challenge.
Traditionally this has been achieved by
pipelines.
A lot could be said about pipelines, but
here it will suffice to say that these
are constructed in some steel material,
and the properties of these materials
are such that the presence of certain
gases must be kept low to ensure the
integrity of the pipeline. Hydrogen
sulfide is a key component as it may
cause stress corrosion cracking.
Pipeline specifications may vary, but
its content is commonly kept below 3–5
ppm. In the US the number 0.25 grain per
100 SCF is often used, but there is no
standard in this matter. It must be
remembered that the flow velocity in gas
pipelines will be too high to allow
integrity for a protective sulfide film
on
the inner pipe wall. For flow assurance
reasons the dew point of the gas must be
engineered before entering the pipeline.
If the temperature is reduced, both
water and hydrocarbons may condense.
Water could form hydrate crystals with
methane and these could block the flow
of gas. Such
hydrates are hard and time
consuming to get rid of.
Clearly no pipeline operator would want
this to happen. Liquid water could also
cause corrosion when acidified by CO2
that is likely to be present in the gas.
This is also undesirable. Finally
hydrocarbon condensate could amass to
quantities that would cause flow
problems if left unchecked.
It must be remembered that pipelines
follow landscapes where its elevation
goes up and down repeatedly. CO2 is
usually also kept below a certain limit,
say 1–4%,
depending on the local situation.
There is also another reason other than
the pipeline considerations to treat
gas. Downstream of the transport system,
that could be complex, there is a
multitude of customers that will use the
gas. Their equipment will have been made
with certain gas specifications in mind.
Here, the gas heating value will an
issue, theWobbe number is often
specified and there will be limits on
H2S and CO2. Corrosion issues apart, H2S
would end up as SO2 in the flue gas and
this would be an environmental problem.
Process Categories
There is limited attention paid to
processing gases in a typical chemical
engineering curriculum. This is,
however, a huge field where many
chemical engineers find employment. In
general terms, there are four
principally different main methods that
may be used to separate gases. They
include (in alphabetical order):
•
Absorption
•
Adsorption
•
Cryogenics: liquefaction and
distillation
•
Membrane permeation.
Ab- and adsorption are often mixed up in
write-ups, probably because their
spelling is so similar. Process-wise
there is a huge difference though.
Adsorption
is essentially a surface phenomenon
while
absorption
involves something being dissolved.
Cryogenics involves gases being cooled
until they condense after which they may
be separated by distillation. Some such
processes could also be argued to lean
towards absorption and/or desorption. A
nitrogen wash unit, sometimes used for
synthesis gas treatment, is an
interesting case with respect to that
kind of discussion.
Membrane technology used for gas
separation is in general based on
so-called dense membranes that separate
gases based on different permeation
rates. Small volume niche
products within inorganic membranes may
be different, but a discussion of this
is beyond
the present scope.
Absorption
Absorption is a much used process for
separating gases, removing undesired gas
components or to prevent pollution from
stacks. The process is, by its nature,
run at supercritical temperature with
respect to the main gas component(s).
There is no boiling like that seen in
distillation columns. The mass transfer
process is generally rate controlled.
All components
are in principle undergoing mass
transfer between gas and liquid, but all
does not need to be accounted for and/or
may be neglected. Mass transfer rates
and mass transfer coefficients may
differ in different directions for
different components.
If a lot of gas needs to be absorbed,
large absorbent flows will be needed.
This represents an operational cost
that, in the end, may be a show stopper
for using absorption.
It is a very interesting process, and is
in many ways the main focus for this
treatise. A separate sub-chapter is
dedicated to a preliminary discussion of
absorption into alkanolamines in view of
these absorbents’
commercial importance.
Adsorption
Practical adsorption processes use a
granulated material with affinity for
the component, or components that are
desired to be removed. This material is
referred to as the
adsorbent,
while the material adsorbed is referred
to as the
adsorbate.
There are four categories of adsorbents
commonly used:
•
Molecular sieve zeolites
•
Activated alumina
•
Silica gel
•
Activated carbon.
There is also a carbon molecular sieve
that is used for making moderate
quantities of nitrogen from air, but we
shall leave that aside. Also liquids may
be treated by adsorption. In gas
treating with absorbents, there is
usually an adsorption treatment of this
absorbent.
Regeneration of adsorbent may be done by
both pressure swing and thermal swing,
or a combination. Pressure swing alone
is a commercial process that is applied
to air separation and at least to
hydrogen recovery from streams of
synthesis gas. In gas treating
contaminant removal by a combination
process involving both temperature and
pressure variation is mainly used. It
could be used to remove water from the
gas, and it is used as pretreatment
upstream of liquefied natural gas (LNG)
trains to ensure sufficiently low dew
points.
Pressure swing implies that the pressure
is changed, and temperature swing
implies that the temperature is changed.
Adsorption processes are
semi-continuous. By this we mean that
they continuously treat the gas without
a buffer volume, the discontinuity comes
from the need to switch between two or
more parallel units. The unit not
adsorbing is being regenerated offline
at a lower pressure and increased
temperature with a heat carrying
dilution gas flowing through.
This dilution gas may need to be a part
of the product gas that most likely will
need to be recirculated. In big units
more than two parallel columns are often
used, sometimes in intricate process
stages to emulate some counter-current
action while regenerating.
Isotherms for commercial adsorbents are
hard to come by. There used to be a
couple of companies that handed out
leaflets with such content, but such
information is certainly not offered on
their web sites. In this context it has
to be kept in mind that these products
are forever being developed such that
isotherms may be improved. It is,
however, nice to be able to make the odd
order of magnitude estimate. This is by
no means the result of a thorough
review, but the isotherms used have been
published by a number of people and such
publications are summarized in Table 2.1
to provide a quick reference as a
starting point.
When both CO2 and water are adsorbed, it
should be clear from Table 2.1 that
water is significantly more strongly
adsorbed and will push CO2 away as they
compete for adsorption sites. In
pretreatment of air for air separation
plants this means that there will be a
CO2 front moving through the adsorption
bed in the direction of flow with a
water front pushing from behind. A
practical aspect of this is that there
is no real need to check for water
breakthrough.
It is actually easier to handle a CO2
detector and a water break-through
would, in any case, be worse for a
cryogenic plant.
On the practical side molecular sieve
zeolites could catch 10 g water per 100
g of zeolite in a practical cycle.
(Suggested as a quick first approach by
a sales engineer a long time ago.
The capacity for CO2 is less. This has
implications for adsorption column
design. When the gas quantity to be
treated is large and the contaminant
concentration is significant, the amount
of adsorbent needed could be become very
large.
Adsorption is mostly used for trace
quantity removal. Specific applications
will be discussed as they arise. They
could include water removal from gas,
and a big application is combined water
and CO2 removal from air feed to ASUs
(ASU=Air
Separation Unit).
There is a lot of research going on in
the hope of finding a solution that may
be used for CO2 removal from flue gas.
Recent adsorbents have been reviewed by
Hedin and co-workers (2013). They point
out that rapid cycling is necessary and
believe that some form of structured
adsorbent is necessary for success.
Treatment of flue gas by vacuum-pressure
swing adsorption (VPSA) has been studied
(Xiao
et al.,
2008).
They tested three-bed designs using up
to 12 steps in the adsorption-desorption
cycle to improve CO2 recovery and
purity. Recoveries reported were in the
range 70–82%,
and purities 82–96%.
In the air separation industry VSA is
used when oxygen purity does not need to
be high, typically 90% although higher
can be provided. Argon follows oxygen
and is one reason why the purity is that
low for reasons of economics.
References:
1. Gas Treating - Absorption Theory and Practice - DAG A. EIMER
2. Fundamentals of Natural Gas, Arthur
J. Kidnay & William R. Parrish |